Applying Psychedelic Experience to Buddhist Philosophy and Practice

Image result for red psychedelic buddha
Art-of-the-Shaman

Within the Western Buddhist community, the discussion regarding psychedelics has revolved around questions like, Are psychedelics beneficial or harmful to meditative practice? Should they be considered prohibited substances according to Buddhist scriptures and vows? Is there knowledge to be gained through their use, or just deeper entrenchment in illusion? . . .

Various spiritual authorities have weighed in on the subject over the last 50 years, including Alan WattsHuston SmithRam DassKen WilberHis Holiness the Dalai Lama, and many others. While the question is still up for debate, many have decidedly taken a position on a spectrum that reaches from unabashed advocacy to total prohibition.

A Spectrum of Views

Spiritual authorities and intellectual figures who strongly promoted the use of psychedelics were people like Ram Dass and Terence McKenna. Early on, when psychedelics were just being introduced into Western mainstream culture, Ram Dass believed in their near limitless potential for addressing societies’ problems and accelerating people’s spiritual development. He and others thought that everyone (55:22min) should take as much as they can. He and his colleague, Timothy Leary, (seemingly) jokingly considered spiking water supplies with LSD in order to “turn on” the population.  The views of early psychedelic enthusiasts best represent an extreme attitude of advocacy. (With time Ram Dass’ views have become more conservative, though).

His Holiness the Dalai Lama sits at the other end of the spectrum (in full-lotus, I imagine), saying that taking psychedelic drugs merely add more illusion to our lives when we have more than enough to deal with already. Michelle McDonald-Smith (pg. 7)believes that chemically-induced experiences, though they may be profound, ultimately have nothing to do with the “natural” cultivation of mind; she sees them as entirely separate techniques that have nothing to say about one another. Others on this side advise against using psychedelics because they view them among the “intoxicating substances” prohibited by the fifth Buddhist precept. Still others fear that the fantastic quality of psychedelic experiences, like the Sirens in Homer’s Illiad¸ may lead one astray from the path of development (the Zen term for this is makyo). Of course, it is a good idea to take into account the extent of such persons’ psychedelic experience. The Dalai Lama admits to having no such experience of his own, and so his opinion of the subject is necessary limited. Some Buddhist practitioners who do have experience, though, express concern that previous trips may have tainted their understanding of Buddhist teachings (although only a small minority in Charles Tart’s 1991 study).

Image result for alan watts by randall roberts
Alan Watts by Randal Roberts

Alan Watts represents a view that stands somewhere in the middle of these two extremes – a very Buddhist place to be. He saw potential benefit for psychedelics on the spiritual path, but thought that their use should not be continued indefinitely. “The ideal of a good doctor is to get rid of you as a patient,” he said. In the same way, psychedelics – as good medicine – should help resolve what they are meant to, and not leave you “hooked on the medicine.” There is no need to keep taking your medicine once you are well. This view assumes that psychedelic experiences can affect one’s “natural” meditation practice, and potentially for the better. It also addresses the concern of getting side-tracked by the fantastic and infinitely-explorable interior landscape of psychedelic experiences, with its recommendation to stop using once insight is achieved.

It is apparent that the discussion within Buddhism about psychedelics is complex and exists on several levels – from an ethical position regarding the fifth precept, to instrumental concerns of harming one’s practice, to fears of becoming distracted from the ultimate goal. The reader should keep these in mind while reading this article. Below, I consider some ways that psychedelic experience may be applicable to Buddhist philosophy and practices. It is filled with references to books, articles and YouTube videos in the hopes of providing the reader with multiple entry points into learning about psychedelics, Buddhism, and their relationship to one another. To start, I’ll consider some direct applications of psychedelic experience to aspects of Buddhist philosophy in general. After, I’ll explore the influence that it could have on three specific Buddhist practices. I’ll finish by discussing the way psychedelics have personally influenced my own practice and understanding of Buddhism.

Psychedelic Experience Applied to Buddhist Philosophy

Psychedelics as State-Training

The way in which psychedelics might be useful in spiritual practice are as forms of state training. To understand this concept, let’s explore philosopher Ken Wilber’s distinction between states and stagesStages are overarching levels of psychospiritual development.Think of them like the different phases you go through in learning math: first you learn the set of natural numbers, then addition and subtraction, then multiplication…all the way up to algebra, calculus, and beyond. Each stage of math “transcends and includes” the previous stage, and allows you to answer more complex questions. In the same way, stages of psychospiritual development transcend and include their predecessors, and allow us to approach the world from a more inclusive, comprehensive perspective.

States, on the other hand, are the conditions of our consciousness at any given time. The normal of set of states that most of us are familiar with are the waking, dreaming, and deep sleep states. If you are reading this paper, you may be familiar with the psychedelic state, as well. An important point is that states are available to us at any stage of development – the caveman of the Archaic Stage enters sleep, dreams and wakes like a Zen Master does.

In line with this, Wilber makes the point that “states are free, stages are earned.” We spontaneously transition between waking, dreaming and deep sleep states without effort, and can have profound spiritual experiences by ingesting different chemicals. Access to a new stage, though, may require years of study, self-work, and meditative practice. From the Buddhist perspective, true spiritual practice is oriented towards reaching higher and higher stages of development, not just acquiring a facility for entering or remaining in transitory states that do not indicate permanent changes in one’s being.

Image result for chakra evolution

What could psychedelics have to do with true spiritual practice, then? Wilber says that “the more you are plunged into a state, an altered state that is bigger than you are…that you can’t interpret…it acts to dislodge, just a little bit, your identification with whatever stage you’re at.” State training, therefore, is the practice of entering “bigger” states to loosen our grip on our current stage. If psychedelics can provide these big states, they may be useful as forms of state-training.

The Preliminaries

If you commit yourself to a Tibetan Buddhist monastery in the morning, chances are that by the afternoon, you’ll be contemplating one of the Four Thoughts that turn the mind from samsara. These Thoughts spring from the core of Buddhist philosophy, and are essential for effective practice. Students must work to assimilate them into the core of themselves – to feel in the depths of their (non-existent) souls. These are known as “the preliminaries,” the things on which one’s later practices will be based. Two that I’d like to note are 1) the contemplation of one’s own death, and 2) the realization of the defects of worldly (samsaric) existence.

  • Contemplation of one’s own death

A well-known occurrence with very high doses of serotonergic psychedelics (especially LSD and psilocybin) are “death,” “near death,” or “death and rebirth” experiences. This experience is so common that Johns Hopkins University is performing a study to see whether people’s psychedelic experiences have altered their ideas about death and dying. In such experiences, people report feeling convinced that they are physically dying, and might experience a sort of “soul-transition,” which they intuit to be part of the natural death process. Some even report (9:26min) a state of familiarity with this transition process.  Here is one individual’s account:

I lapsed out of time and space.  I saw the sky fold up like a book and there was a black abyss beyond it.  I felt my soul leave my body and was sucked up beyond the clouds.  I had no concept of the duration of this, and everything felt eternal, like a dream.  Visions of the end of my life also flashed before my eyes like a 24-hour movie in seconds of time…The entire scene of my death was played out before my very eyes…I actually saw my body lying there, as cold as a cadaver, as I sped back towards it as if I was falling from a skyscraper directly back into it. I took a deep breath of life giving air and gasped.

“Death experiences” like this one can be completely convincing, and may force one to deal with the certainty of their own death. For someone not expecting such a powerful experience, a death-trip would be terrifying, and they might not know how to handle it. For someone prepared to integrate a psychedelic death experience, though, it might be just what they need.

Image result for death meditation buddhism

In order to fully internalize the certainty of their own deaths, many Buddhist monks will meditate for hours in the presence of dead, decaying bodies – preferably human. This is known as “corpse meditation.”  They note the various stages of decomposition that occur after death, and hope to come to the rational understanding that they themselves will undergo this process. Psychonaut Terence McKenna once said that “All spiritual disciplines that I know except for psychedelics put a great deal of emphasis on putting the pedal to the metal. Push, push, push – you know – meditate, make offerings, do Mantrayana, do Pranayama, do Puja, push, push, push! With psychedelics, suddenly there is a very deep interest in ‘and where are the breaks?’” In contrast to the rational, collected method of corpse-meditation, a dramatic first-person experience like the one quoted above might be a useful alternate route for someone hoping to internalize the certainty of their own death.

A Psychedelic Meditation:

On your next trip, take time to ask yourself Stephen Laberge’s three questions:

Death is certain

The time of death is uncertain

What shall I do?

Image result for buddhist monk skeleton

  • Realization of the defects of worldly existence

Many people report coming down from a psychedelic trip with a broader perspective on themselves and on their society. By giving us a comparison with our “normal,” unaltered state of waking consciousness, psychedelic experiences give us something to evaluate our experiences of ourselves and our societies against. For this reason, McKenna equated psychedelics to travel (3:12min): You get a perspective on your own culture by visiting another, which gives you something to compare it against; and it’s peculiar that both experiences are called a trip!

For example, several cultural movements of the 1960s were fueled in part by the temporary adoption of hallucinogens into mainstream culture. Many people adopted practices like vegetarianism, communal living, and bartering systems – all of which romped with traditional values of American culture; and which sound very much like monastic living.

Buddhist literature is replete with accounts of well-off people who renounced their worldly life to expedite their path to awakening. The Buddha (Shakyamuni) himself was a prince living in his father’s palace, being groomed for the throne. Every pleasure was made available to him, but he renounced it all upon realizing that these would not save him from suffering and death; and off he went, in search of deeper satisfaction. This spirit is captured in the song of Prince Candra. After realizing the futility of his comfortable life, “he sang this melodious song”:

My kingdom, which resembles a dream object, is devoid of essence.

Subjects are mere deceptions, illusions.

If I fail to renounce all this and seek enlightenment,

Then I am not a fortunate one who has amassed great merit.

Day and night I shall contemplate the meaning of ultimate nature;

I shall always seek vast and extensive learning.

[Mind Training. Wisdom Publications. 2006. Transl. Thupten Jinpa

For a personal, non-psychedelically-induced story of realization of death and realization of worldly defects, see Josh Korda’s interview on The Wisdom Podcast.]

As seen in the example of the movements of the 60s, complete renunciation of worldly life is not necessary to reap the benefits of the realization being discussed. It is phenomenal, though, how psychedelic experiences do catalyze people to renounce worldly life, enough so that its been called a gateway to Buddhism. Rick Strassman, M.D., is well known for his psychedelic research with dimethyltryptamine (DMT) in the 90s. Strassman was connected with a Zen Buddhist monastery for some time, and had the chance to interview its monks on many occasions. He says that “99% of [the] junior monks all got their start on LSD.”

A Psychedelic Meditation:

On a light future trip, scroll through your Instagram feed and try to discern the cultural forces that people might be aligning themselves with.

Don’t forget to check your own profile.

Related image

Sociocultural Deprogramming

Robert Anton Wilson, in his book Prometheus Rising, expanded on the Eight Circuit Model of Consciousness developed by Timothy Leary in the 1970s. RAW, a Buddhist and psychedelic veteran, proposed that the conscious use of psychedelics and committed spiritual practice can be used towards the same goal: deprogramming ourselves from our sociocultural conditioning. In the Eight Circuit Model, stages 1-4 have to do with the solidification of the most basic levels of our psychology: safety and survival; social power relations; language and time; sexuality and morality. These are the psychological aspects that Leary and Wilson believed form the foundations of our psychological life. In early childhood, we “imprint” certain patterns that determine the kind of person we are, and our perspective on the world. Wilson and others believe that tools like LSD can be used to help us dissolve the solidified patterns of our psyches, and to consciously recast ourselves into new ones. (This is the optional work of the four higher stages of development.)

This initial imprint of our first four circuits corresponds to what neuroscientists call the Default Mode Network. The DMN is responsible for important underlying processes that structure our experience, like self-reference, social evaluations, and thinking about the past/future. Roland Griffiths (3:27min), psychedelic researcher at Johns Hopkins University, has found corresponding changes in the brains of long-term meditators during meditation and non-meditating volunteers on psilocybin (active ingredient in “magic mushrooms”). Both meditation and psilocybin affect the function of the DMN; they interrupt its “tyranny” over the brain’s functioning, and allow different brain areas to communicate that otherwise would not. Herein lies the opportunity for “re-imprinting” – you have melted the metal, and now can recast its form. As McKenna (1:15:26min) states it, “Humanity is unbelievably, perversely locked in closed loops of behaviour patterns and self-deception…And, in fact, where you an outbreak of mass psychedelia, such as LSD, there you get people abandoning fixed behaviour patterns – the stock-broker sells his house and this sort of thing. [Psychedelics] de-condition, and this is a pre-condition for consciousness. How can you evolve your consciousness if you do not decondition yourself from the mold into which it has been poured and ossified?” For long-term meditators, affecting the DMN is available without external supports, but requires thousands of hours of practice; Griffiths calls psilocybin the “crash course.”

The dissolution and recasting of habitual patterns is near and dear to the heart of Buddhism. In the language of the great Tibetan Rinpoche, Chogyam Trungpa, the work is replacing old, irrational beliefs – the way we think the world is – with sane beliefs, which mirror the way the world really is. This entails that the way we have naturally grown to see the world and ourselves is misinformed (6:30min). From the Buddhist perspective, the process of growing up in the world is like the misaligned healing of a broken bone, and the work that needs to be done is to re-break and reset it. In the Buddhist tool kit are many powerful meditative practices which attempt to reformulate our view of ourselves and the world.

Image result for brain wash orna bentor
Brain Wash by Orna Bentor

Jumping from the neurological level to the societal level, Ram Dass (33:40min) believes that psychedelics provide an internal validity to your experience that undermines the external validity of what society and culture have to say. Instead of relying on societal and cultural sources to help structure your beliefs (eg. What is a good life? What kind of things hold value? Who is my neighbour? Etc.), psychedelic experiences possess an authority of their own; and this internal validity helps you form your own beliefs based on your own experiences, Ram Dass says.

De-conceptualization

When we emerge from the womb, we have no intellectual tools to understand the world with. Every piece of sensory input is novel, fresh. There is no possibility for categorization or elaboration; experience just is as it is. But, as we grow, we begin to use symbols and to form concepts that help us understand our environments. Pretty soon, we’re not living in the real world, but the in a conceptual world (9:21min). One of the main aims of Buddhist practice is to systematically dismantle our conceptualizations about the world in order to live in the world as it is, again. Ibelieve a good term for this process is de-conceptualization.

Upon attaining enlightenment, Vimalamitra expressed his understanding thus:

The space of the nature of mind that transcends all thoughts.

[Enlightenment], which cannot be thought,

Is not found by meditating on the ultimate nature of phenomena:

Whether one meditates or not, it is present from the beginning and cannot be lost.

Meditating means abiding in the state of equanimity without thinking!

[The Supreme Source. Snow Lion Publishing. 1999. Chogyal Namkhai Norbu]

Much of what goes in psychedelic experiences is difficult to put into words. Many aspects of psychedelic experience are ineffable. They do not afford conceptualization or verbalization.  In this way, psychedelic agents may give a glimpse of life free from concepts.

It is not the aim of Buddhist practice to merely deconstruct our world and leave it in pieces on the ground, though. This is in accordance with a well-known Zen saying, “Before I came to Zen, mountains were only mountains, rivers were only rivers, trees only trees. After I got into Zen, mountains were no longer mountains, rivers no longer rivers, trees no longer trees. But when enlightenment happened, mountains were again only mountains, rivers again only rivers, trees again only trees.” Through the process of de-conceptualization, we are meant to deconstruct our conceptual outlooks, but then to return to a place where concepts are seen for what they are: just concepts.

Image result for zen painting mountain

For many of us, though, there is still plenty of work to be done in deconstruction. Inducing these experiences with psychedelics may help to free us from our automatic conceptualizations, not only in the moments of a trip, but in our everyday lives. Just as meditation practice is supposed to spill from the cushion into everyday life, “naked” moments of a trip may carry-over into the rest of our lives. There have been several scientific studies that have reported long-lasting effects of psychedelic experiences in changing personality traits (especially the domain called “openness to experience”). It is not unreasonable to assume that other aspects of psychedelic experience, particularly de-conceptualization, could “carry-over” into daily life, as well.

A De-Conceptualization Exercise:

Listen to speech in your native tongue and try to hear it just as sound, rather than as meaningful words.

Interdependence/Oneness

Buddhist practices all ultimately aim at destroying one fundamental conceptualization, seen as the source of all suffering: subject-object dualism. This is the belief that we independent entities that are fundamentally separate from our environments. Psychedelic experience certainly has something to say about this…

In his book, LSD: My Problem Child, Albert Hoffman wrote that

Ego and the outer world are separated in the normal condition of consciousness, in everyday reality…it has become an object. In the LSD state the boundaries between the experiencing self and the outer world more or less disappear, depending on the depth of the inebriation… This experience of deep oneness with the exterior world can even intensify to a feeling of the self being one with the universe.

In Buddhist philosophy, this fundamental oneness, or interbeing, of all things is the fundamental state of the universe. Here, Buddhist philosophy makes a distinction between the absolute and relative levels of reality. On the absolute level, there is only One Thing happening; there is just one continuous Process taking place. Naturally, though, most of us spend our waking hours on the relative level of reality. This is the state of mind in which we exist as persons who are fundamentally separate from our environments – not a bad thing to believe when you are driving to work or running from a bear. Buddhists believe that this relative level is true, in a sense – we do exist as personal subjects in an external world. However, that is not the only level that we exist on. They see the absolute level as true at the same time (2:34min).

Related image
Drawing Hands by Escher

In this way, it is thought that we exist on relative and absolute levels at once, like two sides of the same coin. Following Hoffman’s description of the oneness that can be experienced in the LSD state, psychedelics might provide an opportunity to explore the other side.

Emptiness

Robert Thurman, Ph.D., is professor of Indo-Tibetan Buddhist Studies at Columbia University. He explains that the Buddhist concept of emptiness is not what it might seem like. It does not mean that nothing fundamentally exists, that the true essence of the universe is a vacuum, or something like that. Rather, emptiness is about relativity. It is the idea that things which exist do so relative to an observer. The theory is that, because no two observers are the same, no two perceived universes will be either. For example: two people look at an apple…is each person’s apple the same? Not according to the Buddhist doctrine of emptiness – each has his own personal apple that differs according to their particular perception of it. And they do not just apply this doctrine to fruit…

Thomas Nagel asked What is it Like to be a Bat?, which uses echolocation to perceive its surroundings. Is the apple really a group electromagnetic waves of 500nm (red), or is it a series of 83kHz soundwaves? Quantum physics asks: are photons waves or particles? The answer to both these questions is that it depends on the instrument you use to observe it. The instrument of perception for human beings is, of course, the nervous system, and its functions drastically change with the addition of psychedelic chemicals. With the addition of 300 micrograms of LSD, for example, a routine walk through the park could turn into an exploratory mission through the forests of an alien planet. With this power to alter our perceptual instruments, it may be possible to gain insight into Buddhist emptiness by realizing the relativity of our own point of view.

Image result for psychedelic bat
Danielle Clough

Metaphysics

As psychedelics can take us beyond the ken of our everyday experience, they may cause us to re-evaluate the type of world we live in. Here are a few abnormal occurrences that people sometimes report:

  1. Entering hell or heavenly realms; being transported to other dimensions, alternate universes, distant galaxies
  1. Encountering or interacting with extra-terrestrial entities
  2. Re-experiencing your birth and/or past lives

A list of incredible occurrences could go on forever, but these three experiences map onto Buddhist metaphysics particularly well.

  1. Other Realms

There are six realms of existence in Buddhist cosmology. In descending order, there are the realms of gods, demi-gods, humans, animals, hungry ghosts, and the hells. Of course, on psychedelics you could feel as though you have died and truly gone to heaven, and experience the bliss of a loftier realm of existence. Alternatively, claustrophobic places of despair and darkness could also be on your travel itinerary. It is important to note that people often describe such experiences not only as a state of mind, but as places – they feel they have entered a particular hell or heaven realm.

  1. Entities

Someone once asked McKenna what happens at doses above the 5-7 gram range for psilocybin (Cubensis) mushrooms . He replied that the +8 gram range is where alien abductions and other such strange encounters tend to occur. Encounters with extra-terrestrial entities are not uncommon when using psychedelic agents. The chances of meeting the thousand-armed, buffalo-faced Buddha Yamantaka grow higher with the size of your dose, though; and certain chemicals are known to be more reliable than others. Dimethyl Triptamine (DMT) is especially well-known for producing alien encounters. In Buddhist cosmology, different beings inhabit each of the six main realms of existence, and some depictions, like Yamantaka, are just as weird as the beings some people encounter in DMT hyperspace.

Image result for yamantaka
Yamantaka
  1. Past Lives

Stanislav Grof is one of the founding fathers of psychedelic psychotherapy (now 86 years old), and has conducted thousands of psychedelic-assisted sessions. One of the most prominent themes that Grof noted from his years of research was that people often “regress” so profoundly as to re-experience their own birth, or even beyond:

It is not…unusual to experience, on the level of cellular consciousness, full identification with the sperm and the ovum at the time of conception. But the historical regression does not stop here and it is possible to have experiences from the lives of one’s human or animal ancestors, or even those that seem to be coming from the racial and collective unconscious … Quite frequently, the experiences that seem to be happening in other cultures and historical periods are associated with a sense of personal remembering; people then talk about reliving of memories from past lives, from previous incarnations.

[Psychology of the Future by Stanislav Grof]

Buddhists believe in the theory of reincarnation – that our psychological continuum will carry-on after our bodies die, and will enter other bodies in the future. Instead of being met with bewilderment and disbelief, a psychedelic past-life experience might not be so confusing for a Buddhist practitioner.

In general, the metaphysical universe of Buddhism – with its multiple realms of existence, plethora of extraterrestrial entities, and theory of reincarnation – has a vaster scope than the average Western belief-system. One Buddhist practitioner said that “Tibetan Buddhism or Hinduism, with its flashy trappings and enormous numbers of deities and practices, was more like my psychedelic experiences than anything else I came across. Although the essence of Christianity might be the same, what I learned in church was more the opposite.” Buddhist metaphysics might be able to offer a helping hand to people who have psychedelic experiences whose content reaches beyond the scope of their belief system.

No-self

Through sociocultural deprogramming, de-conceptualization and realizing emptiness, Buddhists hope to reach the state of anatman – literally, “no-self.” The doctrine of no-self is that we are not fundamentally independent, intrinsically existing beings (even though it damn-well feels like it). Buddhist philosophy says it’s this belief that keeps us tethered to the wheel of samsara (birth and death), and that is the foundation for all our suffering. It is thought that realizing the truth of no-self is liberation, therefore, because it is seen that there is no person there to go on suffering and reincarnation.

“Ego-death” is a term used in the psychedelic community that refers to the experience of losing the feeling of personhood. It is the loss of any personal point of reference to experience. This is most likely to happen only on very heavy doses. Ego-death occurs for all of us, though, every night when we go to sleep. The difference with psychedelic experiences of ego-death is that they are a lucid dismembering of oneself. There is full consciousness as a psychedelic agent alters the self-program that our brain is running. Dr. Robin Carhart-Harris is the Head of Psychedelic Research in the Centre for Neuropsychopharmacology of Imperial College (an impressive title), and he believes that ego-death experiences occur when our brains’ “subject” and “object” networks get mixed up:

The Default Mode Network…is concerned with self-referencing, with a sense of self, with looking inwards. Then we have the Task-Positive Network that is concerned with “object,” “external” and “other” … We see that the activity in these networks is competitive; as one goes up, the other goes down … What happens under psilocybin is that we see a collapse in this competitive relationship between the two networks. So rather than being either-or, or winner-takes-all, they become, essentially, one. They become the same network. They blend together…[and] this underlies the loss of subject-object differentiation.

[MAPS Podcast with Robin Carhart-Harris – 43:40min]

Carhart-Harris’ research provides insight into the physical mechanisms that produce the experience of anatman.

A Meditation:

Sit somewhere in nature and close your eyes. After a few deep breaths, listen to the sounds around you and ask why they feel “other,” while the thoughts that enter your head feel like “self.” Try to mix-up your brain’s Default-Mode and Task-Positive Networks.

Image result for eugenia loli head explode
Art by Eugenia Loli

Possible Applications of Psychedelic Experience to Three Buddhist Practices

Dream Yoga

“Train to view all phenomena as dreamlike,” wrote Tibetan master Atisa hundreds of years ago. Injunctions like this can be found in the scriptures of all Buddhist lineages, reaching all the way back to the teaching of Buddha (Shakyamuni) himself. This is such an important part of Buddhism because it is seen that it’s our belief that things are realwhich makes us suffer. Reifying the objects of consciousness creates the potential for suffering.

Andrew Holecek is a respected Western authority on the Buddhist discipline of Dream Yoga. As he describes it, Dream Yoga consists of nighttime lucid dreaming practices as well as waking daytime practices (the practice of “illusory form,” mentioned below). In a recent interview in Tricycle, a Buddhist magazine, Holecek said that

We suffer because we take things to be real, and we suffer in direct proportion to how solid we make the contents of our mind. The teachings on dream yoga and illusory form go to the heart of the matter, because they show us how we create our own suffering by making things so real—so solid and heavy. The removal of suffering is a direct effect of seeing the world as dreamlike. We use our study of nighttime dreams to understand the mechanics of our suffering and happiness in the so-called daytime dream.

[How Far Are You Willing to Wake Up? Tricycle interview with Andrew Holecek]

The practice of illusory form consists of reminding yourself throughout the day that things are not actually as they appear, but are really just dreamlike appearances that have a convincing quality to them. It is practicing remembering that your mind is creating waking reality like it does your dreams.

The word “psychedelic” means “mind-manifesting” (from the Greek: psykhe delos). This points to the ability of psychedelic substances to bring into awareness aspects of the mind that are not normally perceived, whether in the form of visual hallucinations, strong emotions and thoughts, etc. The etymology of the word leaves one inclined to think that psychedelics may be linked to experiencing the dreamlike-ness of reality.

Some prominent ancient Buddhists have drawn direct parallels between the two. In The Treasury of Wish Fulfilling Gems, Kunkyen Longchen Rabjam wrote of that the nature of phenomenal reality is “just like a Datura hallucination…selfless and unreal.” Several psychedelic plant substances were known to ancient Buddhists, but it is officially unknown whether they employed them in their practices. People like Tibetan lama and Sanskrit scholar, Mike Crowley, Ph.D., argue psychedelics played an integral role in the development of Vajrayana Buddhism.

Image result for trippy buddha

By providing a clear example of the way in which our minds manifest reality, psychedelics could be a useful adjunct to the practice of illusory form of Dream Yoga.

Yidam Practice

Yidam practice, also known as Deity Yoga, is an essential vehicle to enlightenment in Vajrayana Buddhism. A yidam is a higher spiritual entity which you devote yourself to for purification and guidance. These “higher spiritual entities” are somewhat analogous to Carl Jung’s idea of archetypes of the collective unconscious. Yidam represent supra-personal qualities and states of being that lay at the foundation of human psychology; they viewed as “deeper” aspects of ourselves. Through visualization, mantra, and physical movement yidam practice attempts to trick you into self-identifying with the yidam.

This practice is found all over the world, though. It makes part of formal religions as well as primitive shamanic systems. In Catholicism, for instance, some people feel a strong connection with a certain saint and perform special prayers and rituals that strengthen their relationship with the saint. In protestant Christianity, the only yidam permitted is Jesus Christ, Himself. Shamans in aboriginal cultures may associate themselves with an animal spirit, such as the bull, the wolf or the crow. Western meditation master Shinzen Young uses the Virgin of Guadalupe as his yidam; “Ave Maria” is his mantra.

Related image
Jesus Malverde by Laurie Mckenna

Below is the account of Frederick Swain. Swain journeyed to Oaxaca, Mexico, without knowing any Spanish, searching for the legendary mushroom shaman Maria Sabina. He encountered Sabina, and she agreed to facilitate a ceremony for him. After some difficult initial experiences, Swain says he

realized that everything is a state of mind. I am free and master of myself. I am whatever I believe myself to be, if my belief is strong enough. My mind was released from its struggle and I felt the strength of a giant, like a god…The Mazatecs…looked at me and chanted, “Santos, Santos, Santos,” in unison.…I really began to feel like Santos, whoever he is. I became identified with a mental image of Santos that took shape in my mind, accompanied by a feeling of ecstasy… I rose on one foot, light as a feather, and turned slowly on my toes. I had perfect physical control and began to do the eagle dance…I began to chant in Mazateca and moved and swayed to the rhythm of my chanting. It all came as naturally as breathing the air.

[Teonanacatl: Sacred Mushroom of Visions by Ralph Metzner]

Image result for shaman eagle

Fred’s profound transformation has the hallmarks of traditional yidam practice: visualization of the yidam, mantra/invocation (Santos, Santos, Santos), and the experience of merging with the yidam. (Just for interest’s sake: Fred knew no Spanish, let alone Mazateca, before his experience.)

If you are thinking of attempting a psychedelically-fueled yidam practice, though, take into account the example of Robert Anton Wilson. At the peak of an LSD trip, Wilson performed the invocation of the Holy Guardian Angel (a yidam of Western esoteric “magick”), and “became convinced [he] was receiving telepathic instruction on consciousness expansion from somebody in the system of the double-star Sirius.” Be prepared for the bizarre…

Loving-Kindness Meditation

Mahayana Buddhism sees compassion as an indispensable factor for awakening. To attain higher stages of development, it is necessary to develop bodhichitta. “Bodhi means our ‘enlightened essence’ and chitta (Skt. citta) means ‘heart’ or ‘mind’, hence the translation ‘the heart of enlightened mind’.” Loving-kindness meditations are practiced to awaken this quality so that we may open our hearts to all living beings. You can feel what is meant by bodhichitta in the words of Shantideva, written in 700 A.D.:

May I be the medicine and the physician for the sick. May I be their nurse until their illness never recurs…

May I become an inexhaustible treasure for the destitute. With various forms of assistance may I remain in their presence.

For the sake of accomplishing the welfare of all sentient beings, I freely give up my body, enjoyments, and all my virtues…

[A Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life. Snow Lion Press. 1997. Transl. Vesna A. Wallace, B. Alan Wallace. Shantideva.]

Though it is not a “classic” psychedelic, MDMA can produce psychedelic effects; but the part that distinguishes it most from other psychoactive chemicals is its capacity to “open the heart.” People may describe feelings of unity and brotherhood with people they do not even know, and care for the welfare of all types of living things. Ralph Metzner and Sophia Adamson describe MDMA’s heart-opening effects:

Teachers and practitioners of meditation and other forms of spiritual work describe the experience as being fundamentally an opening of the heart-center…[T]he opening (even partially) of this center is seen as the foundation for all further psychospiritual growth and practice…

For most, the heightened and deepened state of awareness facilitated by the drug [MDMA]serves as a kind of preview, as it were, a taste of the possibilities that exist for much greater emotional openness and relatedness than they had imagined.

[“The Nature of the MDMA Experience and its Role in Healing, Psychotherapy, and Spiritual Practice” by Ralph Metzner and Sophia Adamson]

Tonglen is a Buddhist loving-kindness meditation practiced in the Mahayana and Vajrayana lineages. In tonglen, you imagine that you have a bright white light burning in the middle of your chest. You then visualize another person and imagine inhaling their general sufferings, in the form of black smoke, into this white light, where they are dissolved and destroyed. Feelings of well-being, like peace, sanity and compassion, are then “exhaled” back to the person in exchange. MDMA could be of potential benefit in such a practice where the generation of compassion is used. Indeed, some practitioners report benefits of its use in their meditative practices.

Image result for is tonglen awesome
Tonglen

For of psychedelic experience to more Buddhist practices, see my Psychedelically Infused Buddhist Practices.

Personal Remarks and Conclusion

            On a sunny Tuesday afternoon, amidst the wheat fields of an empty stretch of highway, I met my current teacher. An elderly man dressed in dark-red monks’ robes and with an umbrella to shade his bald head, I picked him up as he was hitch-hiking to make his annual dental appointment. Over the past few months, I have visited him many times in his forest cabin where he lives. He has become my preceptor in taking formal refuge, and a dear friend who cares for my well-being. Leon, 76, is an ordained monk in the Sakya tradition of Tibetan Buddhism. He underwent an 8-year retreat (alone and in a cave, no less), and studied for years under Dezhung Rinpoche, his root-teacher. As it is said one can only progress so far on the Buddhist path without a living embodiment (9:34min) of the teachings, I made a plea to the universe for a qualified lama to guide me. I view my chance encounter with Leon, happening shortly thereafter, as a response to my earnest request.

Leon has constantly emphasized that the goal of spiritual practice is to cultivate what he calls true-seeing. This does not refer to physical eye-sight, but to perception as a whole (of which eye-sight is just a part). I can only briefly describe here what I believe Leon means by true-seeing. True-seeing, he says, is the crystal-clear experience of things as they are – an intuitive penetration of experience that cuts-through delusive thought and self-deception. This seeing is to be used to “behold the reality and absolute worth of ever being” one encounters. It allows you to comprehend another’s situation in its entirety in order to act with precision in guiding them to liberation from “the heavy chains of hope and fear that bind them to the painful web of their own illusions.” Love, he says, is not the desire to see another person happy, but to see them free. Precise action is the means to bringing this about, through true-seeing.

This teaching has caused me to re-evaluate my motives regarding psychedelics, and to ask whether they are helping me towards this goal or not. Looking back at my experiences, I view them to be instrumental in my overall development so far. I see trips as incubation periods – times of rapid growth and revelation that I then attempt to integrate into daily life. I believe that psychedelics have indeed helped me in each area explored above, and that these lead to the goal of true-seeing. From leading me to seriously take into account the certainty of my own death, to the belief that my conscious will continue on in some form after it – from gaining a new perspective of the culture I live in, to de-programming myself from the beliefs it has instilled in me – from discovering that I am connected to everything and everyone, to gradually uncovering that I am no one in particular – I believe psychedelics have expedited my progress in learning and implementing Buddhist teachings.

The contemplation of my death instills an energy of urgency within me to act wisely with the time I have, and the realization of the defects of worldly existence helps to point that energy in the direction of self-development, rather than to external aims of life. This focused energy then fuels my efforts in practices – like the practice of illusory form, deity yoga, and lovingkindness meditation – that lead to deprogramming, de-conceptualization, and a saner reorientation of my perspective. By these practices I hope to come to a greater and greater experiential understanding of the truths that I have briefly experienced in the unaltered waking state, have glimpsed in psychedelic states, or have only heard rumours of: interdependence, emptiness, and no-self. I hope that as the lived experience of these things grows in my life, I will come closer to true-seeing.

Image result for eye  painting famous
The False Mirror by Rene Margritte

Though I believe that psychedelics have been instrumental in my development so far, I do not see myself taking them forever. Along these lines, Alan Watts once said, “Once you get the message, hang up the phone.” In response to this, though, a wise old man once said to me, “Yeah, but don’t you think you should check the line once in a while to see if you have any missed calls?” It would be arrogant to think that we might have nothing more to learn from these miraculous substances.

Image result for psychedelic phone ]

Disclaimer:

Because many psychedelic substances are illegal, and because I am not expert in their effect and usage, I wouldn’t directly recommend their use to anyone. I am only certain about my own experiences – and barely those. Around the legal issue, though, there are legal methods, which should still be used with the proper preparations. This is worth the consideration of anyone open to exploring alternative means to psychospiritual development, regardless of tradition.

Gio Bruno

Dec 1, 2017

 

Advertisements

Author: psychedelicdharma

A Vajrayana practitioner who will consider any means to the development of his consciousness.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s